State level agreed-upon factors contributing more effective policymaking for public sector services for effective local-level work with NEETs

https://doi.org/10.46841/RCV.2021.04.04

Authors

  • Heidi Paabort University of Tartu
  • Mai Beilmann University of Tartu

Keywords:

NEET, Policy creation, policy coordination, information flow, multidisciplinary service, Youth Guarantee, Estonia

Abstract

Supporting young people who are not in education, employment or training (NEET) represents a new global policy challenge. There is a need to increase knowledge about policymaking connected to multidisciplinary approaches in order to provide better services for NEET youth. This study focuses on interpretations by specialists in the youth field in Estonia regarding the current public policy support system for NEETs and the associated factors affecting the achievement of policy goals. Based on document analysis and semi-structured interviews with specialists from all levels of the national NEET support system, this study demonstrates that the cross-sectoral and multi-level public policy system for NEETs lacks sufficient understanding of the central aims. The support strategy is, rather, created for use within a single structure and does not have a common meaning from a system-wide perspective. State-level coordinating parties need a common understanding at the beginning of policy creation concerning the system’s long-term aims, information flow and performance, agreed-upon roles transcending sectors, and process management across structures. This change would enable better outreach and integrated services at the local level and be accurately based on the needs of youth with heterogeneous backgrounds whilst avoiding barriers at the individual case level.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biographies

Heidi Paabort, University of Tartu

Institute of Social Studies
Doctoral student
Estonian Social Insurance Board, Adviser of Youth Guarantee
Address: Paldiski mnt 80, 15092 Tallinn, Estonia.
Email: heidi.paabort@ank.ee

 

Mai Beilmann, University of Tartu

Research Fellow in Sociology
Institute of Social Studies
Address: Lossi 36,  51003, Tartu,  Estonia.
Email: mai.beilmann@ut.ee

References

Ajzen, Icek (1991). “The Theory of Planned Behavior.” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 50, 179−211.

Avila, Tais Brias., and Rose, Jo. 2019. “When Nurturing Is Conditional: How NEET Practitioners Position the Support They Give to Young People Who Are Not in Education, Employment or Training.” Research in Post-Compulsory Education, 24, no. 1, 60−82.

Barham, Catherine., Walling, Annette., Clancy, Gareth., Hicks, Stehhen., and Conn, Sarah. 2009. “Young People and the Labour market.” Economic & Labour Market Review, 3, no. 4, 17−29.

Beck, Vanessa. 2015. “Learning Providers’ Work with NEET Young People.” Journal of Vocational Education & Training, 67, no. 4, 482−496.

Bonnard, Claire., Giret, Jean-François., and Kossi, Yann. 2020. “Risk of Social Exclusion and Resources of Young Neets.” Economie et Statistique, 2020 (515−517), 133−154.

Cabasés Piqué, M. Àngels., Pardell Veà, Agnès., and Strecker, Tanja. 2016. “The EU Youth Guarantee – A Critical Analysis of Its Implementation in Spain.” Journal of youth studies, l, no. 5, 684−704.

Coleman, James S. 1986. “Social Theory, Social Research, and a Theory of Action.” The American Journal of Sociology, 91, no. 6, 1309−1335.

Council of the European Union. 2013. Council Recommendation of

April 2013 on Establishing a Youth Guarantee: 2013/ C 120/ 01. Brussels: Official Journal of the European Union.

Csoba, Judit., and Hermmann, Peter. 2017. ““Losers, good guys, cool kids” the everyday lives of early school leavers.” Monitoring of Public Opinion: Economic and Social Changes. No 6. P. 295—312.

Edelenbos, Jurian., van Meerkerk, Ingmar., and Koppenjan, Joop. 2017. “The Challenge of Innovating Politics in Community Self-Organization: The Case of Broekpolder.” Public Management Review, 19, no. 1, 55−73.

Escudero, Verónica., and Mourelo, E. L. 2015. The Youth Guarantee Programme in Europe: Features, Implementation and Challenges. Geneva: ILO.

Estonian Ministry of Finance. 2018. Operational Programme for Cohesion Policy Funding 2014−2020.

Estonian Ministry of Social Affairs. 2018. Youth Guarantee Implementation Plan.

European Commission. 2020. Council Recommendation on A Bridge to Jobs − Reinforcing the Youth Guarantee and repleacling Council Recommendation of 22 April 2013 on establishing a Youth Guarantee.

European Commission. 2021. Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions Empty. The European Pillar of Social Rights Action Plan.

Eurostat. n.d. “Young People Neither in Employment Nor in Education and Training by Sex, Age and Labour Status (NEET Rates).” Last modified June, 2021. https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=Statistics_on_young_people_neither_in_employment_nor_in_education_or_training.

Garcia-Fuentes, Juan. 2019. “The Visibility of 'NEET' Young People in the Spanish Economic Context.” Psicoperspectivas, 18 (3).

Görlich, Anne., and Katznelson, Noemi. 2018. “Young People on the Margins of the Educational System: Following the Same Path Differently.” Educational Research, 60, no. 1, 47−61.

Hammarström, Anne., and Ahlgren, Christina. 2019. “Living in the Shadow of Unemployment – An Unhealthy Life Situation: A Qualitative Study of Young People from Leaving School until Early Adult Life.” BMC Public Health, 19: 1661.

Hansen, Morten Balle., Steen, Trui., and de Jong, Marsha. de. 2013. “New Public Management, Public Service Bargains and the Challenges of Interdepartmental Coordination: A Comparative Analysis of Top Civil Servants in State Administration.” International Review of Administrative Sciences, 79, no. 1, 29−48.

Henderson, Joanna L., Hawke, Lisa D., Chaim, Gloria., and Network, N. Y. S. P. 2017. “Not in Employment, Education or Training: Mental Health, Substance Use, and Disengagement in a Multi-Sectoral Sample of Service-Seeking Canadian Youth.” Children and Youth Services Review, 75, 138−145.

Holte, Bjørn Hallstein. 2018. “Counting and Meeting NEET Young People: Methodology, Perspective and Meaning in Research on Marginalized Youth.” YOUNG, 26, no. 1, 1−16.

Holte, Bjørn Hallstein., Swart, Ignatius., and Hiilamo, Heikki. 2019. “The NEET Concept in Comparative Youth Research: The Nordic Countries and South Africa.” Journal of Youth Studies, 22, no. 2, 256–272.

Hooghe, Liesbet., and Marks, Gary. 2003, “Unraveling the Central State, but How? Types of Multi-Level Governance”. American Political Science Review, 97, no. 2, 233−243.

Hudson, Bob., Hunter, David., and Peckham, Stephen. 2018. “Policy Failure and the Policy-Implementation Gap: Can Policy Support Programs Help?” Policy Design and practice, 2, no. 1, 1−14.

Hutchinson, Jo., Beck, Vanessa., and Hooley, Tristram. 2016. “Delivering NEET Policy Packages? A Decade of NEET Policy in England.” Journal of Education and Work, 29, no. 6, 707−727.

Hämäläinen, Kari., Hämälainen, Ulla., and Tuomala, Juha. 2014. “The Labour Market Impacts of a Youth Guarantee: Lessons for Europe?” Government Institute for Economic Research Working Papers, (60).

Jongbloed, Janine., and Giret, Jean-François. 2021. “Quality of Life of NEET Youth in Comparative Perspective: Subjective Well-Being during the Transition to Adulthood.” Journal of Youth Studies, [s. l.], 1−23.

Karyda, Magdalene. 2020. “The Influence of Neighbourhood Crime on Young People Becoming not in Education, Employment or Training.” British Journal of Sociology of Education, 41, no. 3, 393−409.

Katznelson, Noemi. 2017. “Rethinking Motivational Challenges amongst Young Adults on the Margin.” Journal of Youth Studies, 20, no. 5, 622−639.

Kelly, Elish., McGuinness, Seamus., O’Connell, Philip J., Haugh, David., and Gonzalez Pandiella, Alberto. 2015. “Impact of the Great Recession on Unemployed Youth and NEET Individuals.” ESRI Research Bulletin, 2015/1/3.

Kolouh-Soderlund, Lidija. 2013. 10 Reasons for Dropping-Out. Nordic Welfare Centre. Nordic Centre for Welfare and Social Issues.

Kolouh-Soderlund, Lidija. 2015. Overcoming Challenges of Youth Unemployment in the Baltic Sea Region. Nordic Centre for Welfare and Social Issues.

Kolouh-Söderlund, Lidija. 2016. Relationship between Young People and Welfare Services. Nordic Centre for Welfare and Social Issues.

Kusa, Natalia., and Jasiak, Kinga. 2020. “An Analysis of NEETs Situation in UE-28 Countries and the Example of Netherlands.” Przegląd Politologiczny, 3, 39−51.

Luhmann, Niklas. 1995. Social Systems. Stanford: Stanford University Press.

Luthra, Renee., Högdin, Sara., Westberg, Niklas., and Tideman, Magnus. 2018. “After Upper Secondary School: Young Adults with Intellectual Disability not involved in Employment, Education or Daily Activity in Sweden.” Scandinavian Journal of Disability Research, 20, no. 1, 50−61.

Maguire, Sue. 2015. “NEET, Unemployed, Inactive or Unknown – Why does it Matter?” Educational Research, 57, no. 2, 121−132.

Maguire, Sue. 2018. “Who Cares? Exploring Economic Inactivity among Young Women in the NEET Group across England.” Journal of Education and Work, 31, no. 7–8, 660−675.

Mascherini, Massimiliano. 2019. “Origins and Future of the Concept of NEETs in the European Policy Agenda.” Youth Labor in Transition, 503−529.

Mascherini, Massimiliano., and Ledermaier, Stefanie. 2016. Exploring the Diversity of NEETs. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.

Mascherini, Massimiliano., Ludwinek, Anna., Vacas, Carlos., Meierkord, Anja., and Gebel, Michael. 2014. Mapping Youth Transitions in Europe. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.

Mascherini, Massimiliano., Salvatore, Lidia., Meierkord, Anja., and Jungblut, Jean-Marie. 2012. NEETs: Young People not in Employment, Education or Training: Characteristics, Costs and Policy Responses in Europe. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.

Meadows, Donella H. 2009. Thinking in Systems. London: Sustainability Institute.

Nielsen, Mette Lykke., Grytnes Regine., Gorlich Anne., and Dyreborg Johnny. 2017. “Without a Safety Net: Precarization among Young Danish Employees.” Nordic Journal of Working Life Studies, 7, no. 3, 3−22.

OECD. 2015a. Education at a Glance 2015: OECD Indicators. Paris: OECD.

OECD. 2015b. “NEET Youth in the Aftermath of the Crisis: Challenges and Policies”, OECD Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers, No. 164.

Osborne, Stephen P. 2018. “From Public Service-Dominant Logic to Public Service Logic: Are Public Service Organizations Capable of Co-Production and Value Co-Creation?” Public Management Review, 20, no. 2, 225−231.

Passey, Don., Williams, Sadie., and Rogers, Colin. 2008. Assessing the Potential of e-Learning to Support Re-Engagement amongst Young People with Not in Education, Employment or Training (NEET) Status: An Independent Research and Evaluation Study. Overview report. Lancaster: Becta.

Petmesidou, Maria., and González, Menéndez María C. 2019. “Policy Transfer and Innovation for Building Resilient Bridges to the Youth Labor Market.” Youth Labor in Transition, 163.

Rikala, Sanna. 2020. “Agency Among Young People in Marginalised Positions: Towards a Better Understanding of Mental Health Problems.” Journal of Youth Studies, 23, no. 8, 1022−1038.

Russell, Lisa. 2016a. “Complex Pathways for Young Mothers outside Employment, Education and Training.” Ethnography and Education, 11, no. 1, 91−106.

Russell, Lisa. 2016b. “The Realities of Being Young, Unemployed and Poor in Post-Industrial Britain.” Power and Education, 8., no. 2, 160−175.

Ryan, Louise., and Ló́rinc, Magdolna. 2013. Interrogating Early School Leaving, Youth Unemployment and NEETs. Understanding Local Contexts in Two English Regions. Educação, Sociedade & Culturas, no 45, 2015, 33−54.

Saczyńska-Sokół, Sylwia. 2018. “Supporting NEETs? Challenges Facing Labor Market Institutions in Poland.” Oeconomia Copernicana, 9, no. 1, 159−173.

Sadler, Katy., Akister, Jane., and Burch, Sarah. 2015. “Who Are the Young People Who Are Not in Education, Employment or Training? An Application of the Risk Factors to a Rural Area in the UK.” International Social Work, 58, no. 4, 508−520.

Scandurra, Rosario., Cefalo, Ruggero., and Kazepov, Yuri. 2021. “Drivers of Youth Labour Market Integration across European Regions.” Social Indicators Research, 1–22.

Sergi, Vittorio., Cefalo, Ruggero., and Kazepov, Yuri. 2018. “Young People’s Disadvantages on the Labour Market in Italy: Reframing the NEET Category.” Journal of Modern Italian Studies, 23, no. 1, 41−60.

Serrano Pascual, Amparo., and Martin Martin, Paz. 2017. “From ‘Employability’ to ‘Entrepreneuriality’ in Spain: Youth in the Spotlight in Times of Crisis.” Journal of Youth Studies, 20, no. 7, 798−821.

Simmons, Robin., Thompson, Ron., and Russell, Lisa. 2014. Education, Work and Social Change. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

Simões, Francisco. 2018. “How to Involve Rural NEET Youths in Agriculture? Highlights of an Untold Story.” Community Development, 49, no. 5, 556−573.

Stea, Tonje Holte., Abildsnes, Eirik., Strandheim, Arve., and Haugland, Siri Håvås. 2019. “Do Young People Who Are Not in Education, Employment or Training (NEET) Have More Health Problems than Their Peers? A Cross-Sectional Study among Norwegian Adolescents.” Norsk Epidemiol, 28, no. 1−2, 89−95.

Suttill, Beth. 2017. Self-Identities of Young People on a Course for Those Who Are Not in Education, Employment or Training. PhD diss., University of Leicester.

Tatar, Merit., Käger, Maarja., Vollmer, Maarja., Kivistik, Kats., Aruoja, Kertu., Somelar, Andra., and Pertšjonok, Anastasia. 2017. Tegevuse “Minu esimene töökoht” vahehindamine. Vahehindamise aruanne. [Mid-term evaluation of „My First Job“. Mid – term evaluation report.] Tallinn: Balti Uuringute Instituut & Sotsiaalministeerium.

Thompson, Ron. 2011. “Individualisation and Social Exclusion: The Case of Young People Not in Education, Employment or Training.” Oxford Review of Education, 37, no. 6, 785−802.

Vancea, Mihaela., and Utzet, Mireia. 2018. “School-To-Work Transition: The Case of Spanish NEETs.” Journal of Youth Studies, 21, no. 7, 869−887.

Voorberg, William., Bekkers, Victor., and Tummers, Lars. (2015). A systematic review of co-creation and co-production: Embarking on the social innovation journey. Public Management Review, 17(9), 1333–1357.

Windsor, Duane. 2017. “Value Creation Theory: Literature Review and Theory Assessment.” In Stakeholder Management. Published online: 30 May 2017; 75−100.

Published

2021-10-29

How to Cite

Paabort, H., & Beilmann, M. (2021). State level agreed-upon factors contributing more effective policymaking for public sector services for effective local-level work with NEETs. Calitatea Vieții, 32(4), 1–24. https://doi.org/10.46841/RCV.2021.04.04

Issue

Section

Studies