Coming Out of the Shadows? Housing Conditions of Irregular Migrant Workers in Spanish Agricultural Enclaves
Keywords:
immigrant workers, agriculture, housing, irregularity, activism, quality of life, SpainAbstract
The development of industrial agriculture in Spain has been accompanied, in recent decades, by an itinerant, recurrent and temporary mobility of immigrant workers between different productive enclaves. Although this group presents a wide internal diversity, an important segment of it is made up of workers in an irregular situation who participate in the seasonal circuit and who reside temporarily in some of these intensive production geographies. Their employment in conditions of informality makes them highly susceptible to extreme forms of labour exploitation, and to widespread difficulties in gaining access to a non-precarious legal status, which has turned their lives into an overlapping succession of chronic forms of social and labour exclusion. Additionally, the lack of political will, along with institutional and social racism has condemned many of these migrants to extreme forms of housing exclusion that has led them to reside in abandoned buildings, and spatially segregated informal settlements. In this article, we focus on this housing dimension, analysing the intersections between having an irregular status, performing agricultural work, and experiencing a subaltern spatial – residential situation. However, far from aiming to reproduce a passive vision of this issue, we analyse how migrants themselves have tried to respond to this situation. Recently, they have channelled a mobilization around the right to live in dignified conditions that has integrated demands for regularization, demands articulated around labour rights, and demands for the right to decent housing in the enclaves where they reside, thus contesting a deeply rooted policy of indifference that extends to the host societies.
Downloads
References
Achón, Olga. 2014. “Desvagabundizando La Mano de ObraExtranjeraEnEspaña.” Revista de EstudiosSociales, 48: 69–83.
Avallone, Gennaro. 2014. “Migraciones y Agricultura En Europa Del Sur: Emergencia de Un Nuevo Proletariado Internacional.” Migraciones Internacionales, 27: 137–69.
BoletínOficial del Estado. 2021. Resolución de 29 de noviembre de 2021, de la Secretaría de Estado de Empleo y Economía Social, por la que se publica el Acuerdo de Consejo de Ministros de 16 de noviembre de 2021, porel que se apruebael Plan Estratégico de la Inspección de Trabajo y Seguridad Social 2021−2023, December 3, 2021. https://www.boe.es/diario_boe/txt.php?id=BOE-A-2021-20005.
Calavita, Kitty. 2005. Immigrants at the Margins. Law, Race, and Exclusion in Southern Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Cáritas. 2013. La situación social de las personas temporerasagrícolas. Madrid.
Caruso, Francesco. 2015. La Politica Dei Subalterni. Organizzazione e Lotte Del Bracciantato Migrante Nel Sud Europa. Roma: Derive Approdi.
Caruso, Francesco. 2016. “Fragole Amare: Lo Sfruttamento Del Bracciantato Migrante Nella Provincia Di Huelva.” In Agromafie e Caporalato−TerzoRapporto, edited by FLAI-CGIL, 265–80. Roma: Ediesse.
Castillero, Soledad. 2021. La esencialidad del cuartomundo. “Las marroquíes y losmorenos” en la salvaguarda de la producción alimentaria en la frontera sur. Revista de EstudiosSociales, 78: 128−143.
CEPAIM. 2013. Informe sobre las condiciones de vida y las intervencionesenasentamientos de la Fundación CEPAIM. Madrid.
Corrado, Alessandra. 2018. “Is Italian Agriculture a ‘Pull Factor’ for Irregular Migration − and If so, Why?”. Brussels. Open Society European Policy Institute.
Corrado, Alessandra, Carlos De Castro, and Domenico Perrotta. 2017. Migration and Agriculture. Mobility and Change in the Mediterranean Area. London: Routledge.
Décosse, Frédéric. 2017. “« Wanted but Not Welcome »Les Programmes de Migration Temporaire à l’épreuve Du Temps.” In Migrations et TemporalitésEnMéditerranée. Les Migrants à l’épreuve Du Temps (XIX−XX Siècle), edited by Baby-Collin, Virginie, Mazzella Sylvie, Mourlane Stéphane, Regnard Céline, and Sintes Pierre, 131–44. Paris: Khartala.
Defensor del Pueblo. 2020. El defensorpide que se garanticenlos derechos laborales y las condiciones de habitabilidaddignas para lostemporerosagrícolas. Nota de prensa, 21 de julio de 2020. https://www.defensordelpueblo.es/noticias/situacion-trabajadoras-trabajadores-temporeros/.
Defensor del Pueblo Andaluz. 2001. Informe al Parlamento. Sevilla.
Fanjul, Gonzalo, and Ismael Gálvez-Iniesta. 2020. “Extranjeros, Sin Papeles e Imprescindibles: Una Fotografía de La Inmigración Irregular EnEspaña.”. Madrid. PorCausa.
FECONS. 2017. EstudiosobrelosAsentamientosChabolistas. Huelva.
FitzSimmons, Margaret. 1986. “The New Industrial Agriculture: The Regional Integration of Specialty Crop Production.” Economic Geography 62 (4): 334–53.
Gadea, María Elena, Andrés Pedreño, and Carlos De Castro. 2017. “Producing and Mobilizing Vulnerable Workers. The Agribusiness of the Region of Murcia (Spain).” In Migration and Agriculture Mobility and Change in the Mediterranean Area, edited by Alessandra Corrado, Carlos De Castro, and Domenico Perrotta, 79–94. Abingdon.
Garcés-Mascareñas, Blanca and Güell, Berta. 2021. Temporerosagrícolasencontexto de pandemia. Nuevascaras de un viejoproblema. Anuario CIDOB de la Inmigración 2020: 86−100.
García, Pablo. 2021. “El 42% de las 7.137 inspecciones de Trabajoenel campo a las empresasterminóensanciónporfraudelaboral” Infolibre, August 2, 2021. https://www.infolibre.es/economia/42-7-137-inspecciones-trabajo-campo-empresas-termino-sancion-fraude-laboral_1_1207817.html.
García-Castaño, Javier; Agrela, Belén. and Martínez-Chicón, Raquel. 1998. La presencia de trabajadoresextranjerosenel mercado laboral de la recogida de aceituna en la provincia de Jaén. Granada. Universidad de Granada y Diputación de Jaén.
García-Juan, Laura. 2021. “The Disruptive Regularisation Mechanism in the Spanish Law That Challenges the Reform of the Common European Asylum System.” Migraciones. Publicación Del Instituto Universitario de EstudiosSobreMigraciones, 51: 31–60.
García Padilla, Francisca; Sánchez Alcón, Miriam;Ortega Galán, Ángela;de la Rosa Díaz, Jesús. ,GómezBeltrán, María Piedra and Ramos Pichardo, Juan. (2021). Condiciones de vida y salud de la población inmigranteenlosasentamientos de Huelva. Revista Española de SaludPública,95, 1−17.
Garreta, Jordi;Llevot, Nuria; González, Jose;Mara, Anna; Julià, Ramón; Pelegrí, Xavier; Domingo, Jordi; Miranda, Xavier; Allapuz, Rafael and Torres, Teresa. 2016. Els temporers a les comarques de la plana de Lleida. LLeida. Observatorio Permanent de la Immigració.
Gertel, Jörg, and Sarah Ruth Sippel. 2014. “Epilogue: The Social Costs of Eating Fresh.” In Seasonal Workers in Mediterranean Agriculture. The Social Costs of Eating Fresh, edited by JörgGertel and Sarah Ruth Sippel, 246–52. London: Routledge.
Giménez, Carlos. 1992. Trabajadoresextranjerosen la agriculturaespañola: enclaves e implicaciones. EstudiosRegionales, 31: 127−147.
Güell, Berta and Garcés-Mascareñas, Blanca 2020. Agricultural seasonal workers in times of COVID-19 in Spain. Barcelona. ADMIGOV (Advancing Alternative Migration Governance) Project.
Iglesias, J. et. al. 2021. Lo que escondeelsosiego. Prejuicioétnico y relaciones de convivencia entre nativos e inmigrantesen barrios populares. Madrid: Fundación FOESSA.
Langreo, Alicia, and Luís Germán. 2018. “Transformaciones En El Sistema Alimentario y Cambios de Dieta En España Durante El Siglo XX.” Historia Agraria 74: 167–200.
López Mora, Fernando. 2008. “La InmigraciónContemporáneaEnEspaña: Flujos, Problemáticas y Procesos de Regulación.” In Migrazione e IdentitàCulturali, edited by Stefania Taviano, 177–84. Messin: Mesogea.
López-Sala, Ana. 2022. Voices from the fields. Migrant agriculture workers during Covid-19 in Spain and new forms of activism for dignity. EstudiosGeográficos (forthcoming).
López-Sala, Ana. 2021. Luchandopor sus derechos entiempos de Covid-19. Resistencias y reclamaciones de regularización de los migrantes Sinpapeles en España. Revista Interdisciplinar da Mobilida de Humana, 29 (61): 83−96.
López-Sala, Ana. 2016. “Induced Circularity for Selective Workers. The Case of Seasonal Labor Mobility Schemes in the Spanish Agriculture.” Arbor 192 (777): 1–12.
Márquez Domínguez, Juan Antonio. 2014. Jornaleros Extranjeros En España. El Contingente Agrícola de Temporada Como Política de Control de Los Flujos Migratorios. Huelva: Universidad de Huelva.
Martín, María. 2020. “La Muerte de Un TemporeroEn Murcia: Jornadas de 11 Horas a Más de 40 Grados y Sin Agua.” El País, August 3, 2020.
Martínez Veiga, Ubaldo. 2014. “The Political Economy of El Ejido: Genealogy of the 2000 Conflict.” In Seasonal Workers in Mediterranean Agriculture. The Social Costs of Eating Fresh, edited by JörgGertel and Sarah Ruth Sippel, 103–11. Abingdon and New York: Routledge.
Mata Romeu, Anna. 2018. “La Glocalización y Sus Consecuencias: Apuntes Sobre Los Temporeros En La Fruticultura Leridana.” Barataria 24: 209–24.
Mesa de la Integración. 2017. Realidad de losasentamientosen la provincia de Huelva. Huelva.
Molina, Margot. 2020. “Los temporeros de Lepe piden que acabe “elracismoinstitucional” El País, August 5, 2020. https://elpais.com/espana/2020-08-05/los-temporeros-de-lepe-piden-que-acabe-el-racismo-institucional.html.
Molinero-Gerbeau, Yoan. 2021. “The Problem Is Not Covid-19, It’s the Model! Industrial Agriculture and Migrant Farm Labour in the EU.” Eurochoices 20 (3): 69–74.
MolineroGerbeau, Yoan, and Gennaro Avallone. 2018. “Migration and Labour Force Needs in Contemporary Agriculture: What Drives States to Implement Temporary Programs? A Comparison among the Cases of Huelva, Lleida (Spain) and Piana Del Sele (Italy).” CalitateaVieții 29 (1): 3–22.
MolineroGerbeau, Yoan, and Gennaro Avallone. 2016. “Producing Cheap Food and Labour: Migrations and Agriculture in the Capitalistic World-Ecology.” Social Change Review 14 (2): 121–48.
Moraes, Natalia; Gadea, Maria Elena; Pedreño, Andrés and De Castro, Carlos. 2012. Enclaves globalesagrícolas y migraciones de trabajo: convergenciasglobales y regulacionestransnacionales. Política y Sociedad, 49(1): 13–34.
OECD. 2008. “International Migration Outlook 2008.” París.
Palacios, Simón Pedro Izcara, and Karla Lorena Andrade Rubio. 2004. “Inmigración y Trabajo Irregular En La Agricultura: TrabajadoresTamaulipecosEnEstados Unidos y JornalerosMagrebíesEn Andalucía.” Mundo Agrario, 4 (8): 1−21.
Reigada, Alicia. 2012. “Más Allá Del DiscursoSobre La ‘InmigraciónOrdenada’: ContrataciónEn Origen y Feminización Del TrabajoEn El Cultivo de La Fresa En Andalucía.” Política y Sociedad 49 (1): 103–22.
Rye, Johan Fredrik, and Karen O’Reilly. 2020. International Labour Migration to Europe’s Rural Regions. London & New York: Routledge.
Rye, Johan Fredrik, and Sam Scott. 2018. “International Labour Migration and Food Production in Rural Europe:A Review of the Evidence.” SociologiaRuralis 58 (4): 928–52.
Sajir, Zakaria, YoanMolinero-Gerbeau, and Gennaro Avallone. 2022. “‘Everything Changes, Everything Stays the Same’. The Governance of Migrant Labour in Spanish and Italian Agriculture in the First Year of the Covid-19 Pandemic.” EstudiosGeográficos (forthcoming)
Standing, Guy. 2011. The Precariat. The New Dangerous Class. London and New York: Bloomsbury Academic.
United Nations. 2020. Statement by Professor Philip Alston, United Nations Special Rapporteur on extreme poverty and human rights, on his visit to Spain, 27th January−February 2020. https://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=25524&LangID=E.
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
Copyright (c) 2022 Romanian Academy Publishing House
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.